TrackMyRoles vs Teal: Honest Comparison for Job Seekers (2025)

Teal has become one of the most popular job application trackers, known for its AI-powered resume builder and extensive Chrome extension. But is it the right choice for everyone? In this comparison, we put TrackMyRoles against Teal to help you decide which tool better fits your job search needs and budget.

Quick Comparison

What is Teal?

Teal is an all-in-one career platform that combines job tracking with AI-powered tools for resume building, cover letter generation, and job matching. Founded in 2019, Teal has grown to become one of the most feature-rich job search platforms available, particularly popular for its resume optimization tools.

Teal's standout feature is its AI Resume Builder, which uses GPT technology to help you write resume bullets, optimize for keywords, and match your resume to specific job descriptions. The platform also includes a Chrome extension that works with over 50 job boards.

Best for: Job seekers who want AI help with resume writing and are willing to pay $29/month for premium features.

What is TrackMyRoles?

TrackMyRoles is a focused job application tracker built on a simple principle: the tools you need to organize your job search should be free. Rather than trying to be an all-in-one platform, TrackMyRoles excels at what matters most during an active job search: keeping track of where you applied, when to follow up, and staying prepared for interviews.

TrackMyRoles includes Gmail integration that automatically detects job-related emails, helping you capture application confirmations and interview invites without manual data entry. All features are free with no premium tier.

Best for: Job seekers who want a completely free tracker focused on organization, especially those who already have their resume ready.

Detailed Feature Comparison

Job Application Tracking

Both platforms offer solid job tracking capabilities, but with different approaches.

• TrackMyRoles: Clean, focused tracking with company, job title, status, salary, location, and notes. Quick Add lets you create entries in seconds. Pipeline view shows all applications organized by status.
• Teal: Feature-rich tracking with excitement ratings, keyword analysis, and detailed contact management. Works as a CRM for your job search. More fields and options, but can feel overwhelming for some users.

Chrome Extension

Both offer browser extensions to save jobs while browsing.

• TrackMyRoles: Chrome extension for one-click job saving from popular job boards. Extracts job details automatically.
• Teal: More mature extension supporting 50+ job boards. Includes salary data extraction where available. One of Teal's strongest features.

Email Integration

• TrackMyRoles: Native Gmail integration that scans for job-related emails and suggests adding them to your tracker. Detects application confirmations, interview invites, and status updates automatically. Completely free.
• Teal: No native email integration. You need to manually track email communications or use their Chrome extension while browsing Gmail.

Resume Tools

This is where the two platforms differ most significantly.

• TrackMyRoles: Resume storage and version tracking. Upload different versions and track which resume you sent to each company. No AI writing tools. Assumes you have your resume ready or use dedicated resume tools.
• Teal: Comprehensive AI Resume Builder with GPT-powered writing assistance, keyword optimization, and job description matching. The Match Score feature shows how well your resume aligns with specific jobs. These are Teal's flagship features but require Teal+ subscription for full access.

AI Features

• TrackMyRoles: Basic AI for extracting job details from pasted text. Focus is on organization, not content generation.
• Teal: Extensive AI capabilities including resume bullet generation, professional summary writing, cover letter creation, and interview preparation. AI is core to Teal's value proposition but mostly behind the paywall.

Pricing Breakdown

TrackMyRoles

• Free Forever: All features included. Unlimited applications, unlimited resume storage, Gmail integration, data export. No credit card required. No premium tier exists.

Teal Pricing

• Free Tier: Basic job tracking, limited resume builder (1 resume), Chrome extension, basic features.
• Teal+ Weekly: $9/week
• Teal+ Monthly: $29/month
• Teal+ Quarterly: $79/3 months (~$26/month)

Over a typical 3-6 month job search, Teal+ costs between $78-$174. This can add up, especially when you are between jobs and watching expenses.

Pros and Cons

TrackMyRoles

Pros:

• Completely free with no feature limitations
• Gmail integration for automatic email detection
• Simple, focused interface that does not overwhelm
• Fast and lightweight
• Privacy-first approach
• No pressure to upgrade or upsells

Cons:

• No AI resume writing or optimization tools
• Fewer job board integrations than Teal
• Newer platform with smaller community
• No job match scoring feature

Teal

Pros:

• Powerful AI resume builder with job matching
• Extensive Chrome extension (50+ job boards)
• Comprehensive career platform beyond just tracking
• Established with large user base
• Salary data visibility on job listings

Cons:

• Best features require $29/month subscription
• Free tier feels limited and pushes upgrades
• Can be overwhelming with so many features
• No native email integration
• AI-generated content sometimes misaligns with actual experience

Who Should Choose TrackMyRoles?

TrackMyRoles is the better choice if you:

• Want a 100% free job tracker with no limitations
• Already have a solid resume and just need to organize applications
• Value Gmail integration for automatic email capture
• Prefer a simple, focused tool over feature-heavy platforms
• Are budget-conscious during your job search
• Want to avoid constant upsell pressure
• Care about data privacy

Who Should Choose Teal?

Teal might be better if you:

• Need help writing or optimizing your resume
• Want AI-powered job matching and keyword analysis
• Are willing to pay $29/month for premium features
• Apply to many jobs and want automated resume tailoring
• Value a comprehensive all-in-one career platform
• Want salary information surfaced on job listings

The Verdict

Teal and TrackMyRoles serve different needs in the job search journey.

Choose TrackMyRoles if you want a free, focused job tracker that helps you stay organized without any paywalls. The Gmail integration alone can save hours of manual data entry, and you will never hit a feature limit or see an upgrade prompt. It is ideal for job seekers who have their resume ready and just need to manage the application process efficiently.

Choose Teal if resume optimization is your primary challenge and you are willing to invest $29/month. Teal's AI Resume Builder and Match Score features are genuinely useful for tailoring applications to specific jobs. However, be prepared for a more complex interface and the reality that most valuable features require payment.

Many job seekers actually use both: Teal for resume building and optimization, and TrackMyRoles for day-to-day application tracking with Gmail integration. Since TrackMyRoles is completely free, there is no downside to trying it alongside other tools.

Try TrackMyRoles Free

Ready to organize your job search without spending a dime? Sign up for TrackMyRoles in under a minute. No credit card, no premium tier, no limitations. Just a simple, effective tool to help you land your next role.